Hollywood has been flipping books into movies since its onset.
Normally, I would not think about discussing this subject, because, well, it’s nothing new. I don’t mind that good books regularly get turned into� movies. Even though every time it happens- big chunks get ripped out somehow! And in most cases the real moral of the story gets lost.
Yes, I am complaining now, but when a book comes to the big screen, I will most likely be there to watch it. Although, I’d like to add that it’s at the $3 theater.
And let it be known that I am the type of person who will often see a preview and make a point to read the book prior to seeing the movie. This path usually leads me to lose any desire to see the movie, because the picture that the author put in my head is just too good to shatter.
Why do I do this? Because, it took me until the second chapter of Fight Club to get Brad Pitt and Edward Norton out of my head. And they kept popping back in- no matter how hard I tried to make them stay away.

Ya, this guy!
Let’s face it, no matter how messy Brad Pitt’s hair is, he just isn’t the grubby, angry, quick witted, snappy dressing Tyler Durdin I imagined when reading the book. (You might notice his designer T-shirt with motorcycles printed on it in the adjacent picture–not very scuzzy at all! )
Last week I had the same trouble with Coraline, and I have not even� seen the movie.
A major pitfall of books as movies is that the reader has already been given images to use while reading. This takes away a great deal from what the author intended for the reader. And more importantly it discourages the activation of imagination.
Although on that note, I must say that Where the Wild Things Are, is very accurate– but there were pictures!
Alas, a particular preview that I saw this weekend has sparked something in me that just cannot be held back.
Current TV’s The Rotten Tomatoes Show previewed what is expected to be one of this summer’s box office hits: Cormac McCarthy’s The Road.

The Road
Apparently, the release date on this film had been pushed back by over a year, which I am mighty thankful for!
Two weeks ago, I read The Road. It is by far one of the most imagination jogging books I have read! I was so captivated by the book that I� refused to read the last 30 pages when it was dark outside. And I am now (as of my train ride to work this morning) reading No Country for Old Men, also by Cormac McCarthy.
Let’s discuss this a little, shall we?
First off, upon Googling The Road, the first two links to show up were in fact for the movie, NOT the book. The very same thing occurred with Fight Club, only worse! The actual book is not mentioned in the Google list, until the 9th link. And previews haven’t even been distributed in commercial form yet! My problem with this is very plainly, where the emphasis lies– the book came first!
Experiment with this for any book that has turned movie, and I guarantee you will get the same results as I did.
Back on The Road. The previews show more color than my imagination ever pictured! The very mere fact that there are leaves in the movie is in my eyes a horrible misrepresentation of the scenery depicted by the book.
The world was cold and gray, the brightest sun only ever shown through clouds, and the road was covered with ash… NOT LEAVES! This book was so amazingly vivid that I literally ran out last night in the pouring rain to fetch another book by Cormac McCarthy.
Another aspect to the book which I find will be difficult to transfer over to the silver screen is the lack of dialogue between the characters. The sparse conversations that do happen between the man and his son�� are short and spat.
Example:
“You have to talk to me.”
“I am talking.”
“Okay.”
“Okay.”������ –end of conversation until 4� scene building pages later
So, I have not actually used my library card since my beginning as an intern at Open Books. With two weeks until my time is up and my sincere need for some more colorful imagery I decided yesterday was a good day to break it back in…
My goal was to rent Suttery, which, I was told by one of our CAUGHT readers is sincerely a laugh out loud, humorous read. My hope was to see the lighter side of the author whose work is still haunting my dreams.
Unfortunately, Suttery was not to be found. What was there were: three copies of No Country for Old Men, one The Road, and one copy of All the Pretty Horses.
From my brief research while looking for my current read, what I know is that All the Pretty Horses (also a movie) won The National Book Award, and The Road is a Pulitzer Prize winner. No Country for Old Men won four Academy Awards, including Best Picture.
Now, with that information– do you think the fact that one of those books also happens to be a riveting film has anything to do with what I ended up bringing home with me?��������� I’d say it’s possible…
Either way, my moral is that Hollywood is no match for my imagination! No matter the film, I will always keep reading the books!